Thursday, November 9, 2023

Reflecting the Reflection of Reflections

Just saying

Asking a student to include a bibliography for their term paper is deemed by some to be an act of cruelty.  Some of us compile bibliographies for fun (and the advancement of knowledge).  To each his own, right?  I am compiling a Bibliography of Ethical Culture and having way more fun than a woman of my age ought to be having (according to some younger folks who may be somewhat clueless in the joys of living and dinking around in the library).  All of this is to say that another moment of serendipity has led me to further appreciation for the words of Felix Adler and one of those religious experiences that sometimes catch us by surprise.

Here's my story.  I have a more or less organized plan for approaching the Bibliography so that I can document the literature of Ethical Culture over its first 150 years.  (Well, that's the goal.)  There are, however, occasional opportunities to depart from that plan as a source points to more publications that should be documented as well.  In the past, this has led me down side trails to find such hidden gems as the early involvement of Albert Einstein in Ethical Culture in Europe.  This time I found a list of books by Felix Adler and wanted to make sure that I had documented them all in the Bibliography.  One that I had missed earlier was The Essentials of Spirituality, published in 1905.  While trying to find a copy online (out of copyright books are frequently available thanks to Google and Microsoft), I had to check out the full text to make sure that I was linking to a complete scan and not one with missing or blurred pages.  That led me (I said it was a trail) to the last pages of the book where I found this summary of the text:

The leading thoughts I have endeavored to state in these addresses are the following : Spirituality is morality carried out to the finish. It depends on always keeping the ultimate end of existence in view, and on not resting in the partial ends. Intervals set aside for self-recollection and the facing of the thought of death are useful aids. The ultimate end itself is to elicit worth in others, and, by so doing, in one's self. The indispensable condition of this attitude is to ascribe worth to every human being before even we observe it, to cast as it were a mantle of glory over him, to take toward every fellow human being the expectant attitude, to seek the worth in him until we find it. Even toward oppressors we should take the same attitude. Furthermore, our true self resides neither in our poorer nor in our better natural endowments, but in the will that suppresses the one and alone gives moral significance to the other. Finally, we must testify to our respect for principle by treating the small occasions of life as great if they involve a moral issue, and the great prizes of life as small if they are offered at the price of moral integrity. These are thoughts which I have found helpful in my own experience ; I submit them to you, in the hope that they may be of use to you also. [Emphasis added]

Not many days ago, I presented a platform for the Ethical Society of Austin based on the first issue of the journal Reflections published by the AEU in 2017.  My platform was called "Reflections on Difficult People" since that first issue of Reflections focused on responses to a central question:  How should an Ethical treat people that they do not like or who are socially destructive?  Almost all of the responses to that question made reference--direct or indirect--to Adler's An Ethical Philosophy of Life, published in 1918.  For my platform, I summarized the six responses to the question and then summarized my summary with these key takeaways from the discussion:

  1. All humans have worth.  It is inherent and cannot be taken away, nor should it be abused.  Worth is not the same as value.
  2. All humans are connected.  Without belaboring the concept, if we can accept Carl Sagan’s assertion that “We are made of starstuff,” we can grasp the ultimate basis of the connection.
  3. We are bound by our commitments to Ethical Culture to respect the worth of all human beings.  Respect is not the same as love, nor are we required to love all humans.  Respect includes reverence for the best in others.
  4. All humans are unique, and that is okay.
  5. Respect for others includes protecting their worth and dignity from harm, including harm from our own actions.  When we must challenge someone’s actions or words, we must do so with respect.
  6. Human progress includes the development of public norms for protecting the worth and dignity of humans.  Respecting the dignity of others compels us to protect, preserve, and improve those norms.
  7. The practice of Ethical Culture is that which helps us grow or develop as Ethicals (moral beings, ethical units, humane humans).  Such practice may include eliciting the best in others.  It may include treating someone we dislike with respect.  It may include defending the dignity of others while showing all due respect to those who are themselves harming the dignity of those we defend.
  8. Showing respect is not the same as feeling respect.  Sometimes we have to present a facade in order to protect the dignity of the person with whom we are dealing.
  9. Failure is a growing experience.  Use it to become a better Ethical.

I was pretty pleased with my takeaways and felt that I had done a good job of catching the gist of the discussion published in that issue of Reflections.  Imagine, then, my delight in discovering Adler's own summary--a prequel, if you will--to these key features of Ethical Culture.  Imagine, too, the overwhelming sense of wonder that his delightful phrase--"cast . . . a mantle of glory over" the person to whom we are attributing worth and giving respect, with an "expectant attitude" as we seek to bring out the worth that we have already attributed to that person.  The power of these phrases make even more meaningful the words and concepts that I am still seeking to understand, incorporate into my thinking, and embody in my actions.  It doesn't hurt that the words delight me and lift my heart to another plane.

Thursday, November 2, 2023

How to Read Maya Angelou?!

Maya Angelou (public domain)

I have acquired some allergies.  They make me quite miserable--and I seem to be under some stress because of these miseries.  One night recently, I found myself flinching at every sudden noise, ready to cry or explode or both.  I decided to decamp to the bedroom and my reading chair, in hope of some relief.  I found it in reading Maya Angelou's Even the Stars Seem Lonesome.  That calmed me considerably.  I enjoyed her essays on sensuality, on aging, on art and poetry.  I appreciated her use of African proverbs and references to social organization and customs in Africa.  I wept at her description of a "rural museum" in Louisiana and her descriptions of the horrors of slavery.  

As I did so, I wondered at my reactions.  I read half of the volume that night as a means of relaxing.  I read the remainder the following morning with some puzzlement.  Both reading sessions were pleasurable on several levels.  Angelou's writing is smooth and flowing, and it's easy--and pleasurable--to go with her flow.  My puzzlement came from external sources that made me try to understand exactly how I am expected to read her writing.  

Maya Angelou was Black, writing as a Black woman.  She was famous.  She was wealthy.  She was so many things I am not that it is silly to try to list them all.  Nonetheless, her writing resonates with me on several levels.  Age.  Sex and gender.  Living in the South but not actually feeling part of the South.  Love of  words.  Short term residence in Africa.  It also resonates when she talks about slavery and the history that is largely unacknowledged in this country.  It resonates when our experiences and desires take different pathways.  I am not a mother, although I have done some mothering (I am a greater success as a stand-in grandmother), and I read her reflections on her mother and her son from the same (shared) standpoint--and feel that I understand what she is saying.

The puzzlement comes from an earlier reading session--All God's Children Need Dancing Shoes--a few weeks ago, just prior to joining a Zoom session intended to focus on white supremacy.  That session was intended to discuss Layla Saad's Me and White Supremacy, which I had, admittedly, mostly skimmed and only read in bits.  Just coming from a recent reading of Angelou's life experiences in Ghana and having my own experience well in mind from past years in Kenya and Tanzania, I had my own ideas about approaching the issues raised by Saad--including some questions about her perspective and experience.  To me, these ideas and questions are all part of inquiry and seeking understanding.  To the facilitator, they were an expression of my race and my racism.  

That kind of attitude took me aback.  The facilitator (who, by the way was also White) seemed to be taking a fairly dogmatic approach to a set of ideas that were actually the product of someone else's thought and experience--without much actual scientific research.  What has troubled me since then is the increasing sense that some of the approaches I am seeing to Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (with or without the inclusion of Justice) seem more divisive that healing or binding.  Indeed, as I learn more about Ethical Culture, I am finding some of these discussions very much out of sync with respect for the inherent worth of the each individual, including respect for diversity of thought as well as diversity of identity.  I am seeing an emphasis on race (and sexual orientation) with disregard for age, disability, or other factors that combine to make us all unique individuals.  My concern is less with the content of the discussions than the manner, which sometimes belittles or demeans those who are being criticized for the results of systems not of their own creation or actions not of their own doing.

Perhaps I am being naive.  Perhaps this is a reflection of White privilege, White fragility, and White supremacy.  And perhaps I am diverting myself from my central concern:  How can/may a White woman read Maya Angelou?

Returning to that central concern, my response is that a White woman may indeed read Angelou.  She will bring her own experiences to the reading.  Some of them will parallel Angelou's own experiences and allow Angelou's writing to resonate deeply.  Some of them will not parallel Angelou's experiences.  There may be some additional learning needed to approach Angelou's writing--and, very clearly, some learning to be taken from it.  There may be points at which both writer and reader will miss each other.  In reading, Angelou, I am sometimes aware of our differences, but I am also completely drawn in to the universality of her emotions and relationships.  We have a number of social problems related to race in the US and much work to do to resolve them.  Losing sight of our connection to each other is not, I believe, the way to solve the problem.  Finding our commonality, seeing the threads that link us together, realizing how much we are the same is, I believe, a better way.

Thursday, October 26, 2023

Five When You Drive (and Then Some)

    Drive Friendly!    

Ethical Actions come in all sizes.  Some we do together.  Some we do separately but still working toward a common purpose.  Here are some Ethical Actions that we can perform as individuals to have a positive effect on our community and ourselves within or around our personal vehicles.

  • Yield.  The "Yield" sign is a tool for road safety and courtesy.  When a road sign indicates that you are driving in an area where traffic is merging, give way to incoming cars.  Traffic flow will be enhanced, and tempers will stay cool.
  • Yield.  Big rigs are bigger than you think.  Cutting in front on one is neither funny nor safe.  Give them room on the road, and get out of their way.  
    • Lessons from my father continue to echo in my brain when driving on the highway with 18-wheel trucks.  I often take the extra step of slowing down when I see that a trucker is trying to change lanes.  I know that he is on a schedule, has a beast of a machine to keep under control, and is way bigger than I am.  By slowing down, I can give him the extra room to make his lane change.  It really doesn't seem to make that much difference in my own arrival time, but the quick flash of his signal lights lets me know that I've helped in a small way to make the trucker's drive safer and easier.
  • Drive Friendly.  That's a motto that shows up on Texas highway signs ('cuz Texas is the Friendly State!), but it's a good principle for Ethical drivers.  Yes, we want to get from Point A to Point B as quickly and efficiently as possible, but it's not a race.  Nor is it a war, although there are times when the highway does indeed seem like a war zone with cars blinking their lights to get us to move out of their way, others speeding from one lane to another.  
    • Begin your drive mindfully, with the intention to keep it calm and courteous.  One calm and courteous driver may not seem like it will make much difference.  Actually, it may not make the drive better for anyone except you.  The Ethical Action is in not making the drive worse for anyone else.  
    • Lay off the horn.  
    • Use your signals.  
    • Stay within the speed limit.  


Thursday, October 19, 2023

Reflections on Indigenous Peoples' Day

Muriel Tillinghast @ BSEC

I recently visited (October 8) the Sunday meeting of the Brooklyn Society for Ethical Culture. The speaker was a dear friend, Muriel Tillinghast, whose topic was the Indigenous Peoples' Day holiday. We talk about Native Americans little enough in Ethical Culture, though some of Societies do ritually include a land acknowledgement in their meeting programs, that I felt a need to attend the BSEC meeting as much to support Muriel as to hear what she had to say on the topic.

What Muriel had to say was quite powerful.  She talked about history (real history, not the mythology that we were taught in school), language, population (and population decimation through disease, violence, and the genocidal destruction of a primary resource for survival), the very real contributions of Native Americans to this nation.  Muriel also emphasized the existence--and neglect (or worse)--of indigenous people throughout the world.

In the discussion that followed, BSEC members talked about what they had done in the past--and could do in the future--to support Native Americans and learn more about reparations.  One suggestion related to supporting higher education by donating to the American Indian College Fund.  It happens that I agree with that strategy; it's an easy, arm-chair Ethical Action and is one way to work toward achieving the recommendations of UN Sustainable Development Goal #4:  Quality Education.  SDG 4 targets 4.3 and 4.5 are also served by this action.

Several members left the in-person BSEC meeting as soon as it ended to go to a local PowWow.  The Sacred Springs PowWow was held here in my city this weekend.  I didn't attend, but my family did (and came back with multiple tee shirts).  These events are ways to experience elements of the culture of indigenous peoples and learn a little bit about beliefs and crafting practices.  The entrance fees and the purchase of products and foods can contribute to the community.  I was pleased to see that multiple powwows are held around Texas at various times of the year.  Check in with this site to see when and where powwows will be held near you.  (And don't forget to follow the local protocol for visitors.)  I think my family will want to go to more of these events because, yet again, here is an opportunity to show and teach my great-granddaughter about the present as well as the past of our diverse nation.  

There are other ways to be supportive of the indigenous peoples' of our country.  It would, however, be more respectful of those communities to reach out to the various organizations that represent Native Americans in your area to see how you can connect with the programs that they offer and be supportive.  What do they need allies to do?  Would they be interested in speaking to your Society?  Are there issues on which you can jointly participate in advocacy?  Can you begin calling out (and calling in) those in your community who speak ill or falsely about history and living people?  Get started with a simple search:  "Native American community near me."  It's way past time to make up for Columbus!