Showing posts with label Eight Commitments. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Eight Commitments. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 17, 2026

Money, Values, and Technology



We had an interesting discussion of our money and our values at the Ethical Society of Austin on Sunday.  On Monday, I scrolled through my news feed and saw that T-Mobile was inviting (?) Space X to buy it.  Maybe it was another Elon Musk entity, I don't recall, but the association with Elon Musk was enough to settle the issue for me.  I had been, for a while, unhappy about T-Mobile's service and business model, and that news story was enough to overcome my personal state of inertia to make me cancel T-Mobile and choose another cell phone provider.

When it comes to technology in 2026, we don't have a huge number of choices that do not support a corrupt billionaire, so my new cell provider (Consumer Cellular) is backed by AT&T (whose current level of corruption I am not familiar with, but I have no doubt that I could find something that would make me twitch if I looked hard enough).  CC is, however, backed by AARP, and AARP, while not perfect, is active in some areas of concern to me.  

I'm not a trees and fleas kind of girl, so I'm not going to eliminate all technology or comfort from my life.  However, I am willing to do the occasional heavy lifting needed to find ways to put my money to other uses.  In this case, there was enough heavy lifting that I had to pat myself on the back for making it through the maze of changing from my cell service without losing my phone number or my patience with the number of hoops to jump through when leaving one service provider and signing on with another.  

One surprise was the ease of unlocking my phone.  Apparently government regulations do matter for the consumer.  Another was the clarity of the intructions from Consumer Cellular for making the switch.  Given their host and its constituency, such detail and coaching, while not perfect (for me), was encouraging and actually quite supportive.  Would that other technology providers (looking at you, Google) would be similarly clear and detailed.

A theme in this essay is "not perfect."  Nothing seems to be perfect these days---nor am I.  I am willing to accept better over best as I try to make my self and the way I live my life more Ethical.  Ethics does begin with a choice, and this choice is, I believe, a step in the right direction.  

Thursday, July 11, 2024

The Power of Words


Sticks and Stones (Wikimedia Commons)

Words have power.  For all that we learned as children to chant--"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me!'--words can hurt.  They can uplift as well.  The power of words comes not only from what they mean, but how they are used and how they are understood.  We learn, also as children, to seek the denotative meaning of words.  It is only through experience that we learn the connotative meanings and, sometimes, how those connotative meanings send additional messages by how and by whom they are used.

A denotative meaning for "bitch" is the female dog (or wolf, fox, or otter).  How it morphed into an epithet for women, I have no idea, nor do I want to ponder too closely how a woman and dog became somehow similar in the male mind.  These days the word is hate speech--when used as a noun by a male (human) and directed at a female (human).  There are still contexts in which "bitch" can be used as a verb (express displeasure, grumble or complain) without any gender (denotative or connotative) attached to it--except that we have to acknowledge that the behavior being labeled by the verb is understood--if we think about it--to derive from the behavior of the female human who can be called a "bitch" by those males still brave enough to utter the word.

On the other hand, there are contexts in which the word can be used as a positive statement.  Women may choose to label themselves as a "bitch" as a statement of self-empowerment.  Tee shirts, buttons, bumper stickers--whatever medium can be used to assert that power--may read "Super Bitch," "Certified Bitch," and, a favorite, "That's Queen Bitch to you!"  And so on.

I'm thinking now about metaphors and how they shape our attitudes.  "Bitch" does not fit our formal concept of a metaphor, but it is a word used to identify a female animal extended to a new context:  a woman.  We often take words from events and experiences and stretch them to apply to some other thing or action or situation.  In this case, we are seeing a label for a particular animal anthropomorphized (correlating animal behavior to human behavior) to apply to a human with the effect, not only of equating the behaviors (animal and human), but also, and more importantly, to equate the human with the animal.  Once such an equivalence is made, we are thereby permitted to act toward the human as we would act toward the animal.  All too often that behavior is negative, abusive, demeaning.

I am not arguing against animal metaphors or similes, calling for a ban on their use.  Our language is enriched by our creative use of imagery from the world around us.  I am, however, suggesting that we might productively spend some time thinking about our casual use of animal epithets in relation to our fellow humans.  Why did we use that language?  Does this language reflect a tendency toward dehumanizing our fellow human?  Does this language reduce our commitment to respecting the inherent worth of the individual?  In this, I am only thinking in terms of our Ethical commitment to treat each other with integrity.  What are we saying when we use these words--dog, cat, horse, ass, pig, ox, cow, sheep, deer, fox, ape, baboon, rat, weasel, skunk, etc.--to describe another human being?  Is someone who "speaks (too) loudly" the same as someone who "brays like an ass"?  


Thursday, July 4, 2024

One word, Ben: Plastics!

Where too much plastic waste ends up!

Or words to that effect, as I recall that moment in The Graduate when someone leans over to give the new graduate some advice for the future.  That phrase has continued as, I suppose, a meme ever since that remarkable scene.  I think the audience was as taken aback as Dustin Hoffman's character, Ben, was, and that reaction may have contributed to making the scene so memorable.  The advice of that encounter in a 1967 movie turned out to be prescient.  Plastics now dominate our lives on this planet.  Many consumable products are packaged in plastic.  Many products are themselves made of plastic.  Our homes are filled with plastic, and now our bodies seem also to be filled with microplastics.  What this bodes for the future of humans is not good.  The United Nations Development Program advises that the plastics that leach into our bodies from containers and other products:

are linked to serious health issues such as endocrine disruption, weight gain, insulin resistance, decreased reproductive health, and cancer.

In discussing what to do to observe Earth Month in April, members of the Ethical Society of Austin were challenged to "make one change" in use or consumption of plastics.  That change needed to be something that we are not already doing.  That caveat gave me pause.

I have already been "woke" to the dangers of plastics.  I certainly have not done enough to remove plastics from my life and my home.  I do, however, faithfully recycle the single-use plastics that come into my home.  I have two blue plastic recycling bins in which I place the items to be recycled (metal, paper, plastic, glass, etc.).  Whatever goes into those bins is placed in the larger plastic bin that is rolled to the curb every two weeks and picked up for recycling by a contractor with my local government.  I wash the contaminants from whatever goes in those bins to make sure that the items I am recycling are ready for recycling.  

One problem in this process is that so much single-use plastic still comes into my home.  That's why I end up saving a lot of plastic containers for other uses on the theory that repurposing items is also a way to extend the life of the material used to make the plastic.  One container, reused once, reduces the impact of the blob of plastic that made it by 50%--or so the calculation goes.  Multiple reuses of the same container would presumably continue to reduce its impact more and more over time.  In the meantime, if I am buying more of the same product in the same kind of container, I will, at some point, have too many to reuse.  I have, in fact, reached that point with several types of containers.

For the challenge to "make one change," I did make the change to stop buying beverages in plastic containers and switch to glass or metal containers.   Since my beverage of choice is sparkling water, I have plenty of choice in brand and type while sticking to my favorite unflavored drink.  

I do, however, have to be more careful now with the remaining plastic bottles that previously contained said sparkling water.  I have two Pellegrino brand bottles that I saved from a train trip last year, two Topo Chico bottles that showed up from a couple of trips around Texas, and two half-pint bottles that I got for free somewhere.  I like these bottles for their shapes and sizes, and I keep them filled with "still water" in my fridge.  I have sometimes carried them with me on errands, losing a bottle here and there.  These remaining bottles, I have now pledged, will be continuously reused unless I decide to stop using them and send them for recycling.  No new ones allowed.  

I don't know how significant an effect my "one change" will make for the planet, but it does make me aware--every day--that Ethics, to be central, requires making the same choice over and over again.  It has been a challenge to go into the grocery store and not pick up a bottle of water (in plastic) to sip while I shop.  Yesterday, I put a can of sparkling water in my purse, carried it into a big box store, showed it to the greeter, who waved me through.  It's more awkward to keep a can balanced than a bottle with a lid that prevents spills, but at least I'm learning to support my choices with a little advance planning.  

Thursday, January 4, 2024

Time for Commitments

 


When I go for physical therapy, the exercise bike on which I am expected to "warm up" is placed facing a window that looks across the parking lot at a wonderful tree--Chinese tallow maybe--which has absorbed my attention for many "steps" on that bike.  On the wall next to the window is a framed poster:  Commitment to Commitments.  Now and then I read through these statements and compare them to our own Commitments in Ethical Culture.  The list at Texas Physical Therapy Specialists (a fine and caring group of folks) includes a commitment statement followed by a second clarifying statement followed by a paragraph of amplifying examples and scenarios.  The TPTS list goes like this (without the paragraph of amplification):
  1. I commit to Rabid Responsibility.  I own my commitments.
  2. I commit to Confidentiality and Alignment.  I keep confidences.
  3. I commit to Empathy.  I picture myself in the other person's shoes.
  4. I commit to Authenticity.  I acknowledge that I am an intrinsically valuable person.
  5. I commit to Gratitude which Reinforces Humility:  What I appreciate, appreciates.  We rise when we rest on the foundation of Humility.  
  6. I commit to Life-long Learning.  The learning never stops.
  7. I commit to Perspective.  Playfulness and fun make people better.
  8. I commit to Do What's Right.  Very, very Simple:  Would mom approve?
  9. I commit to Serve with Passion.  My passion drives me to make meaningful differences in lives and business.  
  10. I commit to Sisu:  I will face challenges head-on.
Our Eight Commitments are very similar.  We make doing what's right central in our lives and acknowledge that doing so begins with a choice--every day, every time.  We commit to treat each other with integrity, which includes keeping our word, keeping confidences, being authentic and honest.  We commit to treat each other as an end, not a means.  We commit to life-long learning--and democratic processes.  Overarching these commitments, we have the Supreme Ethical Rule:  Act so as to elicit the best in others and thereby in thyself--empathy, gratitude, humility, perspective, and passion.  

The one thing I can't immediately see shared in common in these lists is sisu.  I had to Google that one.  It turns out to be a concept originating in the Finnish language (and culture) that is now becoming more common in English.  It is an amalgam of the concepts embedded in courage, fortitude, stoic determination, and endurance in the face of overwhelming odds.  

At first, it is rather hard to place this within the context of Ethical Culture.  However, when I think about what I am learning about the history of Ethical Culture and Felix Adler's role in nurturing the Movement from its earliest days, I suspect that Adler had more than a little bit of sisu to carry him forward.  From the moment he delivered his first address at Temple Emanu-El, Adler faced challenges and opposition from those who disagreed with him.  As I work on the Bibliography for Ethical Culture, I find articles and commentaries that paint him (and the Ethical Culture Movement) as ignorant or blasphemous or both.  Yet Adler continued to work for the Movement until he died in 1933.  Throughout these many years, he developed and refined his concept of Ideal Ethics and the paths (manifold) we need to take to seek that Ideal, patiently explaining over and over again that our goal is to become better humans and that we do so by working to make the world a better place for other humans to do the same.  As far as I can tell, he didn't give up, nor did he back down.

As we begin a new year, we are faced with some daunting challenges.  Climate change is not a joke.  The possibility that Donald Trump might win the presidency again is a nightmare.  We keep getting closer and closer to nuclear war.  Racism, sexism, inequalities in so many realms--the list goes on and on.  It would be easier to retreat from these issues, to avoid thinking about them.  The thing is:  Ethics is central.  And we need to tell people that integrity matters and how we treat each other matters and that peace is something we make.  It could be time for sisu in Ethical Culture.  Where shall we start?

Thursday, October 26, 2023

Five When You Drive (and Then Some)

    Drive Friendly!    

Ethical Actions come in all sizes.  Some we do together.  Some we do separately but still working toward a common purpose.  Here are some Ethical Actions that we can perform as individuals to have a positive effect on our community and ourselves within or around our personal vehicles.

  • Yield.  The "Yield" sign is a tool for road safety and courtesy.  When a road sign indicates that you are driving in an area where traffic is merging, give way to incoming cars.  Traffic flow will be enhanced, and tempers will stay cool.
  • Yield.  Big rigs are bigger than you think.  Cutting in front on one is neither funny nor safe.  Give them room on the road, and get out of their way.  
    • Lessons from my father continue to echo in my brain when driving on the highway with 18-wheel trucks.  I often take the extra step of slowing down when I see that a trucker is trying to change lanes.  I know that he is on a schedule, has a beast of a machine to keep under control, and is way bigger than I am.  By slowing down, I can give him the extra room to make his lane change.  It really doesn't seem to make that much difference in my own arrival time, but the quick flash of his signal lights lets me know that I've helped in a small way to make the trucker's drive safer and easier.
  • Drive Friendly.  That's a motto that shows up on Texas highway signs ('cuz Texas is the Friendly State!), but it's a good principle for Ethical drivers.  Yes, we want to get from Point A to Point B as quickly and efficiently as possible, but it's not a race.  Nor is it a war, although there are times when the highway does indeed seem like a war zone with cars blinking their lights to get us to move out of their way, others speeding from one lane to another.  
    • Begin your drive mindfully, with the intention to keep it calm and courteous.  One calm and courteous driver may not seem like it will make much difference.  Actually, it may not make the drive better for anyone except you.  The Ethical Action is in not making the drive worse for anyone else.  
    • Lay off the horn.  
    • Use your signals.  
    • Stay within the speed limit.  


Thursday, January 20, 2022

On Hypocrisy and Christianity


After I wrote about the values and ideas that I have taken from Christianity, I happened to read Nathaniel Manderson’s essay in Salon, which was a bit of a righteous rant based on Matthew 23, a longish speech by Jesus of Nazareth condemning hypocrisy.  I ended my essay with a brief and (sadly) flippant reference to how much I loathe hypocrisy but made a poor job of linking it to the things I took from Christianity when I left that belief system behind.


Since then, I have been thinking both about what I might have said about my feelings regarding hypocrisy and Manderson’s essay.  On the one hand, Manderson’s essay resonated with me very strongly.  Manderson’s condemnation of the followers of Jesus who ignore his speech as reported in Matthew 23 fit very neatly with my own sense that many of the Christians that I have encountered personally and read about almost daily in the news are indeed hypocrites.  Reading Manderson’s essay also reminded me that, in my youth, when I believed most strongly in Christianity and the inerrancy of the Bible and tried very hard to be the kind of person that Jesus/God would want me to be, this passage had strongly affected me.  Indeed, with the reminder from Manderson, I realized that this is where I would have learned about hypocrisy and internalized the loathing thereof into my own personal value system.  


I can now more clearly assert that loathing hypocrisy is a value that I took from Christianity.  Indeed, it is the very reason that I left the church of my youth:  I found myself to be a hypocrite and felt that I no longer deserved the fellowship of my church.  In this same period, I was reading Emerson and beginning to think in more naturalistic terms, but the impetus to leave the church was definitely and purely a matter of those strong “Woe unto you” statements in Matthew 23 applied to my own self.  


So what happened?  In a nutshell, I was attending various churches in Houston as a singer.  I sang in their choirs, but as often as possible I “brought the special music” for the day’s service.  At some point, I sat in the choir loft of some church and realized that I didn’t care about the sermon, felt no bond to the congregants in the room, and really just wanted to get to the podium and sing my solo.  Singing was my joy.  My pride.  My whited sepulcher.  I saw that in myself, believed myself to be a hypocrite, and punished myself for it by leaving the church so that I would not be tempted to sing from pride and vanity.


Well, I was young.  Young people often see things in black and white, and I was no different.  I can see now that I pretty much cut off my nose to spite my face with this decision.  It was, however, a genuine reflection of a sincere belief that a hypocrite was not the person I wanted to be.  


These days, however, I still hope not to be a hypocrite, and I am still angered by hypocrisy when I see others espousing one standard and then acting on another, lesser standard.  I think of it as a special form of lying.  Looking around me, I see hypocrisy most clearly in Christians, admittedly because I am biased.  This is likely also because I am tarring all Christians with the same brush, something I truly do not wish to do.  Manderson wrote about evangelical Christians, and he wrote about the kinds of beliefs that I held when I was young, which gave his essay a special resonance with me.  Those beliefs are not, in a surprisingly large part, what progressive Christians believe or practice.  Modern evangelicals, especially those who follow the so-called prosperity gospel, also seem to have moved away from “that old time religion,” albeit more in the direction of commerce and social control.


As an Ethical Humanist, two things come to mind:  One, I think I need to work on my tendency to homogenize all Christians, and, two, Ethical Culture has a role to play in calling out hypocrisy in favor of truth.  It is the first that I will focus on here, but, as I explore, as I plan to do, our commitment to try to act with integrity, I think avoiding hypocrisy and calling it out will both be strong components of our actions.


We may think that identity labels can help us in dealing with others in a respectful way.  It does seem to be true that knowing that someone is, for example, of Jewish heritage may help remind us to be mindful that some foods might be better left off the menu or that some dates should be avoided for meetings.  But not everyone of Jewish heritage is the same in their beliefs or their practices or their experiences.  Someone of Jewish heritage may also carry more than one “identity”:  female, transgender, third generation Dutch, lawyer, even Republican.  The list could go on.  We are each of us complex intersections of our cultural and personal histories.  Applying one label to a person can easily lead us to forget that there may be other important labels to consider and, more importantly, that the person before us is more than just a set of labels or, worse, the stereotypes that go along with them.


I do know that all Christians are not the same.  Christians in more mainstream traditions have a broader view of society and their place in it.  Christians in Europe are more often more secular in their world view.  I would like to remove a few of my stereotypes so that I can feel as well as show more respect (and not be a hypocrite in faking my respect).  The way to do that may include more interfaith work with, say GreenFaith, the Poor People’s Campaign, or even Revolutionary Love, although each of these very worthy organizations make me uncomfortable when their religiosity is expressed in mostly Christian terms. 


My past experience with Christianity was narrow, limited by the doctrines (and policies) of the Southern Baptist Convention.  In later years, I did have occasion to work with “the faith community” in the effort to gain better access to medications for Texans living with HIV and AIDS.  That experience, however, could be described (as I thought of it, in military terms) as a war on two fronts.  While there were allies for the work in the broader Christian community (and indeed with people of other faith traditions), there were also strong opponents who were also “people of faith,” ranting about sins and punishment rather than compassion and care.  O ye hypocrites!  These religious views often distracted attention from the important work of improving both prevention and treatment for HIV through public funding.  I have no doubt that both periods of contact with these Christians influenced my perception of those who believed in this tradition and biased me against the tradition as anti-science and completely hypocritical in proclaiming love with such hate.


At this point, the “war” is within me.  Looking for peace rather than victory, I want to be open to seeing that “diversity in the creed,” using Felix Adler’s framework, should not become a barrier to working together when there is “unanimity in the deed.”  I think, however, that what I am looking for goes beyond the practical matter of working with people whose beliefs I will tolerate.  Tolerance cannot help but include an element of rejection:  “I don’t like what you believe but I will put up with it so we can work together for a common goal.”  That is utilitarian and makes me look at people as a means, not an end, when it is the reverse that I would hope to practice.  


This need to go further comes, I think, from my understanding of religion.  Religion is nothing more than a human construct which functions to serve human needs.  It is vitally important to humans to have this particular kind of construct--it explains the universe and one’s place in it, it provides a basis for human relations, it provides the means to reinforce other structures, such as those for economic and political processes--but there is no single such construct for all humans.   Respecting the diversity in individuals--the unique and complex intersections of their various labels--I would also hope to respect the constructs and solutions which they have chosen to meet their personal needs (which include their individual needs as well as the needs of the communities they seek to construct or maintain).  


Respect implies acceptance more than tolerance.  What I would hope to find in true respect is an acceptance that embraces not only the wide variation in belief that goes with the various constructs that are called “religion,” but also accepts my own need to hold my own such constructs, different and evolving as they are, without rating those who hold different constructs with evaluative comparisons.  That is to say, I would hope to accept that different is neither better nor worse but merely different and to do so with a compassionate recognition that human needs can be addressed in different ways.  What would be important in my understanding, then, is not one or another answer to the question of how the universe came to be but that those who need the comfort of an answer to what is still an unknown can find the comfort that they need in whatever answer they can accept.


Such an idealized version of respect may not, however, survive its encounter with reality.


What happens when I believe that some element of a construct will cause harm to others?  Can I still respect the construct and condemn the harm?  Am I hypocritical to claim to respect another’s belief and yet seek to oppose its practice?


Here’s a reality check.  The Muslim practice of requiring women to wear veils is nuanced.  Neither the same veil nor the same rules for wearing the veil apply from one sect of Islam to another nor in different geographic locations for members of the same sect.  I can accept the various social functions of veiling and whatever ideological justifications are given for veiling as merely different from my own views until the requirement to veil butts up against my own closely held belief that a woman has the right to control her own body, including what she chooses to cover it with.  My limit faces both directions.  The shift in political winds in France has led to a secular government’s ban on a specific religious garb for women.  I would oppose the government’s right to interfere in the woman’s choice.  The shift in political winds in Afghanistan has led to increased control by the Taliban and a requirement that women, who had been free of the veil for a number of years, must now again don the veil--and the severe restrictions that go with it--against their will.  Again, I would oppose that government’s right to interfere in a woman’s choice.  


If I wish to avoid hypocrisy, I need to find a more nuanced construct that allows me to affirm my support for the right to believe differently than I do, but that also allows me to confront a point when competing constructs come into conflict.  To respect the beliefs of others, to accept their right to believe whatever they need to believe in order to live their lives with the hope and comfort that religious beliefs can afford, is not the same as accepting the validity of those beliefs.  More importantly, it is not the same as accepting that those beliefs can and should be carried out in actions that violate my own beliefs about causing harm to other human beings or the environment on which we all depend for life.  


So here’s a construct that may serve to get me to what I want to be.  Religion, as a category of human constructs, has important functions to serve for humans and their various social structures.  Cohesion and survival of these various human societies will depend on their various systems of belief (constructed religions) that may (or may not) include a deity, reverence and obedience to some ideal or principle (often expressed as a deity), and conformity to a varying set of rules, prohibitions, rituals, etc.  That my own break with one of those constructed systems of belief came with a tiny bit of a bang, influenced significantly by the Sage of Concord, but with more than a few emotional scars is, in fact, a personal problem, which I may still have to work out for myself.  However, my Ethical understanding of hypocrisy is leading me to an understanding that the “creed,” whatever it may be, is secondary to the “deed,” whatever it may be, when there is an opportunity to work together for the common good.  That means, I think, that I need to put my past experiences with a specific religion aside in order to work/meet/get along with others who practice other religions for the common good of maintaining our social connection(s) within the broader framework of this modern nation state.  This does not imply hypocritical and false “respect” but asserts the basic and fundamentally shared human solutions to human needs advanced to a more inclusive level that allows pluralism in the more particular details of belief with the occasional necessary adjustments to work/meet/get along.




Saturday, April 17, 2021

First Commitment: Ethics Is Central

 

ETHICS IS CENTRAL.

The most central human issue in our lives involves creating a more humane environment.




At first glance, one can see that there are two crucial elements to the first commitment (to Ethical Humanism), and how one understands those elements will determine how one understands the commitment.  Almost immediately, however, I find that a dissonant note is sounded by the subtext regarding “the most central human issue.”  The subtext seems to override and obviate the need to examine the commitment itself in any broader terms.  I challenge that.  I am willing to consider that creating a more humane environment, broadly defined, is an important, probably even a central issue in our lives, but I cannot, without more thought, agree that it is the most central of all issues.  In any case, I cannot agree that “ethics” and “creating a more humane environment” are sufficiently equivalent to make the latter the definition of the former, i.e., that “ethics” equals “creating a more humane environment.”


Beginning again, the two crucial elements of the commitment are “ethics” and “central.”  While whole books have been written to explore the nature of ethics and much ink has been spilled to argue the difference between “morality” and “ethics,” I am content that Oxford Languages’ (OL) online definition of “ethics'' is sufficient:  “moral principles that govern a person's behavior or the conducting of an activity.”  For my own practical purposes and general understandings, I actually prefer the OL second definition given for “moral” (as a noun)--“a person's standards of behavior or beliefs concerning what is and is not acceptable for them to do”--and will use that as my own definition of “ethics.”  Either way, we are looking at principles and standards for behavior.  


Ethics as a standard for my behavior must come, I believe, from my own experience, knowledge, and reason.  What I learn from experience will serve me as practical knowledge that has revealed both positive and negative results.  I can--and do--learn from both my successes and my mistakes.  I also learn from the experience and knowledge of others.  In some cases, they may tell me--personally or through books and articles--the positive and negative results of various behaviors.  In other cases, I may make my own observations of behaviors and interpret the results as positive or negative.


One of my earliest memories of learning from others’ mistakes came when I was just barely a teen.  The debate in our family was whether I could wear short shorts.  Nice girls didn’t, but I certainly wanted to.  Resentment festered as I looked for ways to push back against the parental edict until one evening we went to the drive-in theater for a family evening.  In those days, parental negotiations ran to the sort of horse-trading that included a Paul Newman movie for Mama and a John Wayne movie for Daddy.  If the double feature included both, it was a win-win.  If not, promises for the future would balance things out.  For me, the excitement was in getting to the concession stand. The rewards might be popcorn, a soda, or even a little bit of boy watching.  On one occasion, there was the need to stand in line to use the facilities.  I happened to see a teenage girl, not so much older than I, with her hair in pin curls, covered by a long pink chiffon scarf.  She wore short shorts.  Really short shorts that had ridden up above her thighs and settled in a manner that revealed more than, perhaps, originally intended.  The image has stuck with me for more than 60 years, likely because it shocked me in my sheltered existence, but also, I think, because it was a moment when my own ethical thinking kicked in.  I reasoned, quite simply, that I did not want to look like that, did not want to show myself in those ways, that wearing short shorts was not going to be “acceptable for me to do.”  


What is also telling about that moment is that it was not my parents’ will that drove the decision.  Nor was it the values of my then affiliation with Christianity coming to the fore.  Had I made the decision not to wear short shorts at any point prior to that trip to the concession stand, I would have to think that I was bowing to the authority and moral dictates of either parents or church or both.  At that moment, however, it was my own observation and reason that said “not me.”  I made the choice for myself, just to be clear, not for Daddy and not for Jesus. That my decision reflected the conservative values of the community in which I was raised made the decision, I believe, no less my own.


I think that my personal experience, while likely unique in content and context, is not all that different from what others have done/are doing as they develop their own standards for what is acceptable for them to do.  They--we--observe.  We read.  We learn.  We analyze.  We reason and decide.  We combine experience and knowledge with reason to exercise our capacity to distinguish right from wrong in ways that include the whys and why nots of how we choose to behave.  In this way we create our own ethics as we live our lives.


There is more to be said regarding the process of creating our own ethical principles and standards for thought and action, but one point should be emphasized at the outset:  We are capable of forming ethical principles through our own human capacities and do not, therefore, require any outside force or authority for our choices.  Laws may compel our action in specific ways, but it is up to our own conscious awareness of right and wrong to decide whether the law is just and whether we will obey it.  Belief in a god may provide a whole list of general principles and specific rules for our behavior; absent such belief we still have the capacity to establish for ourselves a distinction between right and wrong through our own experience, knowledge, and reason.


Take the potato.  As an example of an object in need of the application of ethical principles, the potato is, one would think, a much simpler target than, say, abortion.  And yet the potato is rich with ethical dilemmas and choices well beyond any question of whether to bake or boil.  Seeing a potato on the kitchen counter, one must, for example, decide:  To peel or not to peel.  There is an abundance of tools available for the specific purpose of peeling potatoes, pointing to a strong preference among home cooks to peel.  Indeed, there are largish machines for industrial scale potato peeling pointing to a social and cultural bias in favor of peeled potatoes.  Certainly there are a number of lovely things that one can do with a peeled potato.


The problem, aside from any considerations of the nutritional value locked in the potato’s skin, is, of course, what to do with the peeling.  The potato peel can be considered garbage which, of course, should be disposed of in a sanitary manner lest it become rotting garbage and so attract flies, cockroaches, and other undesirable visitors.  On the other hand, that peeling could be labeled as food waste, a loaded term is ever there was one (food = good; waste of good things = bad; food waste = ethical minefield).


Food waste does not have to be an ethical concern.  Indeed it is not for most Americans.  Our nation wastes as much as a third of all the food it produces.  (Imagine going to the grocery store, buying three bags full of groceries, and tossing one of them into the trash can before you take the rest into your house.  Imagine doing that every time you go to the grocery store.)  For most home cooks, standing at the sink with a handful of potato peelings, the next step is automatic:  Toss them in the garbage can (or the sink disposer if available).  There is no ethical concern if we are unaware of (or uninterested in) what happens to those potato peelings next.  Nor is there an ethical concern about the role of those potato peelings in relation to our community.  There’s not much a few potato peelings can do for food insecurity; one potato’s peelings really won’t add a significant amount to our community landfill.  Any potential for ethical concern is also eliminated if we have already accepted a philosophical orientation to the planet as our gift from a deity so that the earth and its resources are ours to do with as we wish, without consequence or blame for simple waste, which may be the deity’s own will anyway.  Either way, it is not our concern or responsibility.


There is, however, for some of us, that moment when we stand at the sink, potato in hand, and see it as part of something larger.  That potato had a history, a journey, before it came into our hand.  While it may yet have its moment of glory as it is served on our table, there may be within us a degree of concern for what that past history was and how it connects to us through the potato.  There may also be a moment of concern whether we should feel any connection to those parts of the potato that did not make it to our table.  Could we have used the entire potato?  Are we disposing of the remains of the potato in a way that does no harm to us or our community?  What about all those leftovers?


This may, however, be the point at which we should consider the second component of the first commitment:  Central.  


For ethics to be central in one’s life and, therefore, in one’s behavior it must be at the core, the focus, the pervasive and unifying orientation for thought and deed.  If ethics is my standard of behavior or beliefs concerning what is and is not acceptable for me to do, then whatever I do, no matter how insignificant or small, needs to be considered in terms of whether it is acceptable according to those standards, whether it is, in a word, ethical.  I have said “Food waste does not have to be an ethical concern,” and offered various reasons why someone might view ethics as irrelevant in a given situation.  Once, however, we make ethics central, everything becomes subject to consideration of what the appropriate--and ethical--behavior might be in relation to it.


In this sense, we fail to behave ethically if we do not bother to learn about the effect of food waste on the environment.  Our waste can only be ethical if we learn that food waste is not an issue for global warming.  Once we know that food waste can produce greenhouse (heat trapping) gases, we become ethically obligated to see what we can do to avoid or mitigate the waste of food.  We fail to behave ethically if we see ourselves as individuals, not connected to others of our humankind, not connected to the planet from which we sprang (some long time ago), not connected to the star stuff from which our planet came (even longer ago).  To behave ethically, we must seek the knowledge that reveals our origins and our connections and then act as the individual part of the whole system/entity which we are.  Inevitably, that will lead us to proactively shape our actions to sustain ourselves, our community, and the planet of our origins.  We fail to behave ethically when we delegate our responsibility for making decisions about our own standards for what is acceptable to unseen and unverifiable sources.  When such magical thinking allows one to do as one wishes without regard for the consequences, those consequences, if based in the nature of the planet, will nonetheless occur, often to ill effect for the planet, the community, and ourselves. 


So then does making ethics central also make “creating a more humane environment” central?  In Ethical Culture we often say “deed before creed.”  That’s a call to action, saying basically that we should not worry about the ideology when there is work that we can be doing.  It becomes, however, a means of avoiding the question of what the ethical principles are that will guide our deeds.  How do we choose the deeds that we should be doing without some understanding that what we do is, in a word, ethical?  It becomes, moreover, a means to avoid looking at the central transformation that we seek in Ethical Culture, which is to become more ethical in both thought and deed.  We avoid “creed,” and we focus on “deed,” but, if ethics is central, it may well be that we should turn our focus to ethics and the principles that will guide our deeds.


To return to the example of food waste, we realize that there are many reasons why someone would decide that wasting food is a “bad” thing to do.  It may be a matter of thrift.  If money to buy food is in short supply, one would not want to waste any of what can be purchased with those limited funds. Or food itself may be in short supply as we have now seen with broken and slowed supply chains during a pandemic.  We would want to protect our limited resources for the duration, being less wasteful so that our supplies will last.  This seems less a matter of ethics than of necessity, but it may also be that food waste could be viewed as part of a larger concept of waste that is to be avoided (“waste not, want not” is a prudent philosophy).  Not wasting food could also be part of a larger sense that the food on our plate is part of a long chain of supply, with many resources and many hands needed to get it to our plate.  Simply recognizing that long chain connects us to the various points on the food’s journey from seed to supper.  As we are mindful of that connection, we can see the potato on our plate and consider its growth in soil, with the sun and rain to nourish it, with hands that probably belong to a migrant worker earning less than a living wage lifting it from that soil to begin its journey to our table.  Despite the abundance of our circumstances that does not itself require that we conserve food because of scarcity of food or funds, if we are mindful, we know that sun and rain are now subject to the forces of climate change.  Too much sun, too little rain, and the growing of our food becomes less certain, more costly.  The potato becomes part of our connection to the earth:  Whether the soil can sustain growth, whether the climate will be stable enough to provide both sun and rain in appropriate amounts and thus provide the nutrients that we will then take into our body become now a more prominent element of our concern for that connection..  And the migrant worker?  How she lives, where he sleeps, how their children are cared for are also connected to us through the potato.  This connection is not some mystical thread of spirit extending from one person to another; this is no matter of unseen outside forces holding us together as humankind.  It might be the star stuff from which our planet and we are made that connects us in a literal sense, but it is also, I believe, our own reason and awareness that allows us to observe and create/construct those connections.  Once seen, my ethics lead me to believe that I need to respect these connections, not take them for granted, not waste them.


To make ethics central is to make ourselves aware and accept that there is nothing we can touch in our world that is not also bound up with the questions of how we are connected to it and how we should treat it.  From the humble potato to our dearest friend to the stranger at our border, we are connected in multiple and varying ways.  Each of those connections place burdens and constraints upon us as we seek to act in ways that we can believe are acceptable by our own standards of behaviors and beliefs.  This requires, I believe, a continuing process of awareness, analysis, and revision of connections, standards, and principles.


Indeed we may from our experiences, knowledge, and reason derive certain principles related to food waste, such as:

  • We are connected to each other through our origins on this earth.

  • We are connected through our dependence on each other for survival and community.

  • Our connections provide valuable contributions to our personal well being and that of our community.

  • Any product of these connections should be respected for its source, for its value to our well being and community, and for the processes of connection in the long chain from its origin to its final destination.

These principles may apply to other matters aside from food waste.  They may hold for a period of time, providing us with guidance for how we approach the situations in which we find ourselves.  As our experience grows, our knowledge increases, our reason leads us, we may find that new principles may be derived, and these may be revised.  


For ethics to be central in our lives, the only requirement is that we make ethics central.  We begin with a consideration of what our standards and principles may be for what we think is acceptable thought and action.  These may take time to develop; they may change.  We succeed as we manage to remove the distracting needs and drives that push against our wish to focus on ethics as our guide for living.  As we find our connection to the earth and to our fellow humans, we also find ourselves seeking to find ways to protect and nurture those connections as a means to fulfill our own needs and expand our sense of well-being.  In all of these steps, however, what is needed is the intention to focus on ethics and make that the pervasive and unifying orientation for our thought and deed.  Only with the intention to make ethics central can we do so.  As a commitment to Ethical Humanism, we are committing to that intention, to that making, so that in all we do we consider whether what we do is acceptable to our own standards, which are derived from our experience, our knowledge, and our reason.


Carolyn A. Parker