Thursday, September 14, 2023

A Question of Balance

William James,
American Philosopher, Historian, Psychologist

I am overcome with the beginning of William James' speech, "Is Life Worth Living?" (Ethical Addresses, 12th Series, 1905, pp. 1-29).  I hadn't half begun reading it when I had to stop and absorb all that he had thrown at me (and initially at the Young Men's Christian Association at Harvard, c. 1895) in the introduction.  

James began with Walt Whitman's ebullient praise of life, which, of course, lifted me up; then he took me down to the depths of despair with a long excerpt from James Thomson's poem:  "The City of Dreadful Night."  Two pages worth of an excerpt, with this snippet of doom and gloom:

My Brother, my poor Brothers, it is thus : 
This life holds nothing good for us,
But it ends soon and nevermore can be; 
And we knew nothing of it ere our birth. 
And shall know nothing when consigned to earth ;
I ponder these thoughts and they comfort me.

And then he called us back to reality, more or less, with another excerpt from an unidentified source quoting [John] Ruskin, to remind us that joy and misery yet live side by side though one be out of the sight of the other.

And, with that, I had to pause and reflect.  The emotional rollercoaster created by these references took me from high to low to a stricken realization that at no time might we be wholly comfortable in our own lives, knowing that others are themselves suffering and miserable.  What to think?

Sometimes, yes, life is so wonderful we can hardly believe that we have been privileged to experience such moments as come to us with delight and wonder and sheer pleasure.  I can remember the day I was waiting for a Senate Committee hearing to begin, intending to testify in support of some bill or other, thinking:  "I can't believe they pay me to do this."  I can remember the peace and comfort of just leaning sideways slightly to touch my late husband's shoulder and feel the solid support of his presence.  I can remember standing on the back porch of my rented home as a student in Seattle, seeing Mt. Rainer, with sunlight gleaming on its snowy top--all that beauty practically for free!  I can sit here now, in a not wholly lit room, no views to speak of, just a keyboard and monitor to face me--and remember many such moments, delighted at having been given the chance to experience them, delighted still to have the ability to remember them.  (Memory is nothing to take for granted!)

But, yes, there are moments in life where we can hardly stand to bear what we must suffer now and, sometimes, forever.  The loss of loved ones will eventually come to all of us.  I sit here, with my husband's loving glance captured in a long ago picture, knowing that I will never see those eyes looking at me again.  The pain of walking from one room to another, sometimes worse, sometimes better, always a reminder of limitations, keeps me indoors and away from direct social contact--which even an introvert will eventually miss.  The careless insults and assaults that others may fling in my direction, seeking, perhaps to awaken my awareness, not realizing the deep wounds that they re-open.  My woes are few, but sometimes they loom large.  I can find myself descending into the Slough of Despond before I realize what's happening, if I don't carefully pull myself back from the abyss.  Still, rarely, but painfully, I sometimes find myself questioning whether my life is worth continuing.

It is, however, the last of James' three quotations that strikes me the hardest.  I cannot regret my happy memories; I have learned to back away from the abyss.  But how do we live in any comfort or ease, knowing that around us people are suffering?  These walls shut me in.  Now, however, I am reminded that on the other side a good neighbor has recently suffered a stroke.  A young couple have taken in their flags and signs, any indication of their non-binary identity, being now forced to hide who they are out of fear.  Farther away, I am told, young students are facing their own struggles to find their way forward in a society that pushes them in unhealthy and unsafe directions.  And we know that poverty and disease and violence and abuse and the whole litany of horrors that humans can manage to inflict upon humans (and non-humans and the planet itself) continue.  Once we become aware--awakened, if you will--how do we survive the onslaught?

James' address to the YMCA was about suicide--and how to avoid it.  I'm not sure that I am fully aligned with his answer (religious experience will give you a reason to live), so I will have to spend more time with James' work and ideas to see why it so appealed to the editors of Ethical Addresses when they republished it 10 years after it was first delivered.  In spending that time, I am not likely to be seeking an answer to the question at the heart of his essay:  Is life worth living?  (Hell to the yes, it is.  And I'm loving the living of it, aches, pains, stress, and all.)

The question, however, that is going to stalk me for quite a while is the one that struck me so hard in reading James' introduction and is, after all, the key question that faces us in Ethical Culture.  Not "is life worth living?" but "how can we balance our need to grow and change within ourselves against the need to help the world around us develop and change?"  We seek to become better human beings, better family members, better neighbors.  We also feel pulled to help relieve the suffering we see in the world, to help others find better ways to be human.  Do we have to choose between these needs?  Or can we do both?  What is the balance?

I take this issue as a "key question," because I feel that there is an ongoing tug of war ideas within the Ethical Culture Movement right now:  Should we focus our efforts on our individual inner development and not on Ethical Action that focuses on serving the broader community external to our Ethical Culture Societies?   Should we focus on our service to the planet and its inhabitants, or should we tend first to our own need for development as Ethical humans?  Frankly, I think Felix Adler answered that question both ways in the past, and I'm not sure how other Leaders have treated the issue since those early answers.  Perhaps that is why we continue to hear passionate statements like this:  "Ethical Culture Societies, not the AEU, should engage in Ethical Actions!"  "You can't do any Ethical Actions until you have worked on your own attitudes and beliefs!"  "The AEU needs to develop national Ethical Actions that Societies can participate in!"  And on and on, back and forth, with no particular forum or venue in which to seek consensus.

Perhaps it is time to have that discussion.  In the meantime, we must agonize within ourselves, knowing that others suffer, knowing that we can (try to) help, but that we also need to maintain a commitment to ourselves and our intellectual and emotional development as Ethical Humans.  How to do that remains the question, I think.

Thursday, September 7, 2023

Ethical Eating with Barbara Kingsolver


Local Food from a Known Source

At some point in the next few months, I am going to be buried in research and writing about Ethical Eating.  That is the topic of an issue of a journal that I am re-editing for re-publication (it's a long story).  Maximizing the utility of that effort, I have committed to using this issue of the journal--and the issue of Ethical Eating--as the topic for a presentation at the Ethical Society of Austin in the spring.

In the course of re-editing a different volume of the journal, I encountered a reference to Barbara Kingsolver and her novel, Flight Behavior.  A comment she made about that book was quoted in the essay that I was correcting (typos, punctuation, red--or blue--pencil heaven for a former English instructor).  There was, however, no citation for the quote, and I really wanted to add the proper footnote for this reference.  I googled it--and the only hit was the online version of the very article I was editing.  Spftt!  I was apparently searching for a misquote.

TL;DR, I dinked around on the internet to try to figure out some way to find the comment without spending days on it and ended up at Archive.org, thinking I would scope out the novel and, by some miracle, find the quote.  Instead I all but tripped over Animal, Vegetable, Miracle:  A Year of Food Life, by Kingsolver, et al.  I have no idea why I would even give the book a second glance, much less start reading it, but suddenly I was two chapters in and realized that (a) I have completely missed an entertaining author and (b) this is the other half of what I know I will be talking about when I give the presentation on Ethical Eating.

Kingsolver's autobiographical book is about a decision that she and her family made to change the way they eat.  A major part of that decision was environmental.  She lived in Tucson, a desert area in the midst of a drought, where food and water had to be brought in from other areas.  She was concerned that our society--and her family--didn't know where the food we ate came from, how it was grown, or what it could be (tasty, nutritious) when at its freshest.  She--and her family--made the decision to move from Tucson to a farm in the Appalachians that her husband owned so that they could change that situation for themselves.  

Animal, Vegetable, Miracle is a book about a year in food during which the whole family had pledged to eat only locally sourced food.  That sounds simple enough until you take in account that this planet has seasons.  Everything, all at once, all the time is not how food  appears on our plates or even in our local grocery stores.  Part of Kingsolver's thesis is that we have lost our connection to the planet and the sustenance that we take from it.  The other part is that we are destroying the planet by taking too much from it and misusing what we take.  No doubt I oversimplify.  

No doubt either that these points sound negative while Kingsolver's book is positive and proactive and a delight to read.  The family's negotiations about one non-local luxury/essential made complete sense, as 21st century urbanized omnivores were suddenly faced with the loss of foods and beverages long taken for granted.  Kingsolver's husband chose coffee as his personal exception to the rule of consuming local products, and who could blame him?  (Not I, limited these days to one cup in the morning and sorely aggrieved about the whole thing.)  Kingsolver's long history of trying to grow asparagus was neither boring nor tedious.  Her tale was, in fact, heroic--and now I wonder what fibrous green thing I've been eating all these years.  Each chapter brings new insights into how American foodways have changed, what we are missing because of those changes, and what we might do differently.

The book is a delight to read; Kingsolver's style is light and a bit wry.  The message is more than timely:  We need to take as much petroleum as we possibly can out of our food supply.  The whole-family orientation of the book (Kingsolver's husband provides multiple "sidebars" filled with pertinent information; Kingsolver's oldest daughter provides personal narratives of her "adventures with food") and the shared commitment to locally sourced food are inspirational.  

Plus this.  Needless to say, I recommend the book as well as some of the strategies that Kingsolver and her family adopted in order to take petroleum out of their food.  I'm no gardener; I have a seriously bad history with plants.  However, with Kingsolver's encouragement, my grandson and I went to the local Farmer's Market to purchase free range eggs and in season vegetables.  We also found fair trade coffee, albeit sourced from both hemispheres.  It's a start.

Thursday, August 31, 2023

Hanging with Ethicals



Ethical Humans!

Attending a memorial service is not exactly hanging out with friends, but I recently attended one held for Susan Rose Teshu, who died in July.  Even though I never met her in person, I felt a need to attend this memorial service to honor a woman who had been so active in Ethical Culture for so many years and was so clearly beloved by many.  Susan served for several years as the Dean of Leadership Training for the American Ethical Union and, some years ago, well before COVID introduced us all to Zoom meetings, hosted Ethical Society Without Walls, an online community for those who did not live near an active Ethical Culture Society.  

I refer to attending her memorial service in the lighter tone of "hanging out" because, although I didn't know Susan or her family, I knew many who were in the audience.  I also felt instantly included in the group, even though I arrived a few minutes late (time zones bite).  This was more than the sense of familiarity that comes with entering a room of acquaintances.  It was the sense that I was in a room with like hearted people.  "Safe" is the word that is being tossed around these days, and I have to say that I felt safe in a space with few personal friends.  

I think the feeling came from being with people that I knew to be Ethicals (whether they identify as Ethical Culturists or Ethical Humanists).  These were people that I could trust to recognize my worth as a human being and treat me with integrity.

The remembrances expressed about Susan and her life and work were sometimes moving, sometimes not at all clear to me.  I had my own experiences with loss to help me see the catharsis that such remembrances were actively providing for the speakers.  I was also moved to tears as my own remembrances of grief provided a background context for looking at the gallery (as the "room" is called in Zoom), seeing familiar faces, recognizing smiles and deep feelings, sharing the emotions of loss and love.  

I think Susan Rose is part of the reason that these like hearted people could gather in such a way and create a safe space for expressing and feeling emotion. Her leadership and the training she provided--part of a tradition that began many years ago--helped foster this attitude of acceptance and welcome.  I think many of  the people who gathered to honor her do the same for others.  I think part of why they can do that is because Ethical Culture starts with a commitment to attribute worth to each person we meet.  All are welcome, all are accepted, even if they are late, even if they never say a word.  I came to honor Susan; I left healed and strengthened.

Sunday, August 27, 2023

25 Ethical Actions You Can Perform in the Privacy of Your Own Home

Ethical Culture is committed to Ethical Action.  Some folks call it Social Action.  Others stick with Social Justice.  There are differences between these labels, but all of them are pointed toward a central aspect of Felix Adler's "new religion":  That we seek to be better, more moral humans; that we can do so by acting more morally; that we will learn to do better with practice.  That, at least, is my interpretation of what I read in some of the addresses that Adler gave to the New York Society for Ethical Culture and other groups in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.

In leading various Ethical Action committees (for the Ethical Society of Austin and the American Ethical Union), I have observed that many speak of--and practice--Ethical Action as a group activity conducted in the community.  I tend to think that it is how we live our lives--in our ordinary daily activities--that we also put our Ethics into practice, which makes those daily activities Ethical Actions.  

Ethical Society of Austin joins protestors at the Texas Capitol
(Adam Gravois makes an important point)

Here are some examples of Ethical Actions that we can practice in our daily lives.  Almost all of these actions are directed toward the environment--reduced use of resources and recycling of used resources.  Even so, some of these actions can also lead toward some social/community connection as well as involve our Ethical decision making in shopping, both of which will have an effect beyond our homes.  Indeed, all of these actions connect us to the planet and those who live on it, reminding us of the importance of even the smallest action.

Five in the kitchen:

  • (2) Rinse and recycle metal cans (after air drying).  Be sure to drain all liquid from beverage cans before placing them in your recycling bin.
    • This seems like an obvious thing to do, but I've seen wet cans tossed into the bins often enough to understand that not everyone is thinking about the future growth of mildew in the bin and in the recycled cans.  The time delay between the tossing of the can and the actual recycling process can be lengthy enough for all sorts of toxic items to grow, coat the bin(s), and escape into the air.
  • (3) Load your dishwasher carefully, being mindful of the physics of water flow to assure clean dishes.  Run the dishwasher only for a full load (top and bottom!).  Consider turning off the heat drying cycle and allowing your dishes to air dry.
    • My late husband and I had many discussions about the physics of water (it goes down and around, not up or through solid masses) and how that related to the dishwasher.  Now I cringe when I see dishes piled in such a way that water flow is blocked.  Not only is this dangerous (surfaces not cleaned and sanitized), but it is a waste of water and electricity when the machine can't do its job properly.
    • I allow my dishes to air dry when the washing cycle is finished.  This saves a bit of electricity (which makes me feel somewhat less guilty about relying on a machine to wash my dishes).
Five in the bathroom:
  • Turn off the water in your sink when you brush your teeth.
  • Consider purchasing toilet paper made from recycled paper.
    • Soft, fluffy toilet paper is made from fresh-cut trees which have longer and more flexible fibers.  Recycled paper can get the job done without the luxury of wiping with a soft, fluffy item which is sourced from a vital, slow-growing resource.  
    • Check the label on your toilet paper (or contact the manufacturer) to see whether it includes recycled paper and how much.  
    • I use Who Gives a Crap brand toilet paper.  This company uses post consumer waste to make its recycled toilet paper.  It also makes toilet paper from bamboo, a fast growing grass (no trees needed).  
  • (2) Recycle the wrapper and toilet roll core.
    • If the wrapper is plastic, it needs to go along with your other plastic bags for recycling.  If paper, just put it with the rest in your bin.
    • Yes, the cardboard core is recyclable.  (It's also good for crafting and, with a slit up the side, bundling messy computer wires.)
  • Consider saving your leftover soap pieces to make a "new" soap ball.
    • OK, I haven't made a soap ball yet, but I'm saving the soap slivers.  I will, no doubt, make a big deal out of shredding the slivers and making the ball--when the time comes.
Five in the living room:
  • Turn off unnecessary lights.  
  • Do you really need to run the TV in the background?
  • (3) Magazines can have longer lives after you've finished with them:
    • Check with a local senior facility to see if they can use the magazines for their residents.
    • If there are lots of pictures, check with a local school to see if teachers can use the magazines for projects (or for reading).
    • If all else fails, recycle the paper.
Five in the closet/laundry:
  • Wear your clothes longer.  
    • Purchase durable fabrics in "classic" styles that can be worn year after year.  This will help cut the cycle of "fast fashion" and, ultimately, reduce the amount of clothes thrown into a landfill.
    • Unless you are outside in the Texas summer and/or doing heavy manual labor, chances are you can wear that blouse/shirt more than once.  This will reduce the frequency of laundering your clothes and the expenditure of energy resources to do it.
  • Hang dry your clothes rather than using the dryer.  This will extend the life of the fabric (less loss of fiber) and wearability (less shrinkage).
    • Yes, things will be rumpled.  Straighten the cloth as much as possible while still wet.  Iron only if you really must.  Strut the rumpled look when among friends.  😏
  • Wash your clothes in cold water.
  • Wash only a full load of clothes.
    • Yeah, yeah, the manufacturer has settings for smaller loads, using less water.  It still uses electricity for a full cycle.  

78 degrees in the summer;
68 degrees in the winter.

Five for the whole house:
  • Set your thermostat on 78 for the summer, 68 for the winter--and don't touch it.
  • Switch to LED lightbulbs.
  • Turn off the light and the ceiling fan when you leave a room.
  • Use natural light as much as possible.
  • Change your A/C filters regularly.
Most of these things reflect a degree of "common sense" and promote frugality.  Who Gives a Crap Toilet paper is not frugal in terms of the cash that I pay to buy it, but, since I'm not flushing trees down the loo, I am happy to spend the money.  I'm not so good at using natural light when it is available, but assorted nurses have entered my home and started messing with the blinds often enough that I am catching on.  All of this "small stuff" takes some practice and attention to detail until it becomes a habit.  The tradeoff in cost/effort vs benefit may well be in our improved sense of commitment to the earth and our fellow earthlings (of all species) as we succeed in reducing unnecessary demands on the planet's resources and increase our progress toward being the kind of person that we wish to be.