Thursday, October 12, 2023

The Banality of Crazy

My dear friend, Lamar Hankins, regularly sends me news articles that he thinks might interest me, and he recently hit the nail on the head.  He sent me an article by Paul Furhi in the Washington Post:  "Trump’s violent rhetoric is getting muted coverage by the news media."  The point of the article is that, for various reasons, the increasing violence of former President Trump's public speech is receiving decreasing coverage, surprise, or outrage.  His speech is becoming banal--the banality of crazy, as Furhi reports that Brian Klaas (University College London) labels it.  

The article resonates with me at a time when I am trying to work out ways to get the rich legacy of Ethical Culture out of dusty boxes and obscure websites into places where ordinary members of the Movement have easy access and--just as importantly--have awareness of the writings and lectures that have shaped our Movement over time.  One such piece of our legacy I have never heard anyone cite, but I find it quite relevant to our present situation--and the degree to which incitement to violence has become not merely banal but increasingly normalized.

The speech to which I refer is a platform delivered by Algernon D. Black to the New York Society for Ethical Culture on October 1, 1944, entitled "The Meaning of Hitler's Defeat."  As you no doubt realize, Hitler had not yet been defeated at the time Black gave this platform.  He--and his audience--expected Hitler's defeat in a foreseeable future.  Black, however, gave his attention to the notion that simply defeating one man--or even his armies--or even his country--would not be enough.  The ideology being propagated by Hitler and his allies and his armies--fascism--would, even after Hitler's defeat, still have an insidious presence throughout the world and even on American soil.  

Just as it does today.  Black's concern is mirrored as some might seek the political defeat of Donald Trump and still miss the insidious presence of his beliefs that violence is an acceptable way to win, that othering is a desirable political strategy, that money is the primary good in society, and so on down the line to the whole package of fascistic actions, strategies, and outcomes that is part of Donald Trump's plan for the nation.  

Black's conclusion:

There are people in our country who have never voted. They are Americans but they have never bothered. It is too much trouble. They say they are individualists. They never want to join anything. They see no responsibility to give strength to anything. “I live my life, I let other people live. I do my job, make my money, have my pleasure, have my family, that's all.” I say that if America gets Fascism, we of all the countries, who have had freedom longer, who have education and political controls, who have had the chance through all these years to see what Fascism does,--if we fail, we shall deserve everything we get. And if it happens, may history write us down for what we are,--selfish and materialistic, a people without any vision, a people who fight, but do not know why.

Here then is the spiritual challenge of Hitler's defeat. Here, when the war is over, the real war will begin!

And so, let us not be fooled when the military defeat of Hitler comes. Let us make certain that it is the spiritual defeat of Hitler. Victory can only be won on the level of a new understanding and a new citizenship. It requires the reconstruction of democratic faith and the reconstruction of relationships between people, here in America and if we do not have this new life here in America, we shall never be able to help create it in Germany or anywhere else.

The "crazy" that Furhi refers to seems more likely to diminish rather than call out the very real danger posed by Trump's rhetoric--and that of those who support him.  Moreover, the "crazy" is not new. If this is not the moment when America becomes wholly Fascist in its orientation, if this tide of "crazy" recedes, if Trump is defeated, Algernon D. Black's warning of the dangers of the failure to defeat the "spirit of Fascism" will still continue to be relevant.  We grow as Ethicals by putting our values into action through our deeds.  We can only grow as Americans--living up to the ideals of democracy and freedom upon which this nation was founded--by putting our values into action through practicing the principles of democracy daily.  To me, it seems that Al Black is all but shouting that Fascism will only be defeated by Democracy, and it's time for Democracy to step up.  I concur.

Thursday, October 5, 2023

A Whole Different Country

Ethical Culture School

I wouldn't call it a "whole new world," but New York City is definitely a different country from what I experience each day in Central Texas.  The weather.  The streets.  The people.  This trip has surprised me, challenged me, and inspired me.  My central purpose in coming was to work on a research project related to Ethical Culture, so that meant going to the New York Society for Ethical Culture--the Meeting House.  

On my first day, I walked from my hotel via 64th Street toward Central Park.  I was immediately delighted to see a fruit and vegetable vendor right on the corner.  I bought two pears, thinking that would be a healthy boost to my snack stash.  I was also checking out all the shops at street level, to see what services might be there in case of need.  Almost immediately I came to the Ethical Culture Fieldston School just as students were arriving.  Teens meeting and greeting on the steps.  Little ones shepherded in by a parent.  An actual school bus dropping off a couple of dozen or so younglings.  What a delightful sight.  I took a moment to think about the school's history and origins in Ethical Culture, to think about what a fine education these children would be receiving, and was quite cheered.  Unlike the battle zone that Texas schools have become, I thought how these children would be allowed to question, to explore, to wonder in ways Texas children will not--sitting in classrooms marked with "In God We Trust," the ten commandments, and all sorts of religious indoctrination.

It took but a few minutes to find the entrance to NYSEC and roll myself up the ramp to the door.  A nice lady named Jody let me in and took me up to the 5th floor where the NYSEC administrative offices were.  I was early, but I had a comfortable place to sit and lots of things to look at.  The artwork on the walls.  Brochures.  Posters promoting NYSEC events.  There was plenty to take in.  Then Donna Pang arrived, and the day took off.  Donna is retired from the administrative offices of the American Ethical Union (which are located on the fourth floor).  Her interest in the Ethical Culture archives inspired her to come meet with me to talk about the archives.  But first a tour of the building!

Donna took me to see the places where the archives are stored--some well organized and very high cabinets, some jumbles of boxes mixed in with other random junk.  Clearly preservation is as high a priority as access (my own goal).  We also visited the Elliott Library and Adler Study.  In the latter, I think we struck gold--a complete set of The Standard--which I hope to be able to look at more closely before I head back to Texas.  

Adler Hall -- At the Door

Our final stop on the tour was the Meeting Hall--now called Adler Hall.  I struggled to climb the steps to enter this space that I had seen only in photos and videos.  There were a few people in the Hall, eating their lunch and talking quietly.  Donna and I sat on the edge of the platform and tried to take it all in before one of these renting the space informed us that they would soon resume their preparations for another event and would we please leave soon?  A disappointment.  I did not get my chance to "stand where Felix Adler stood," but I was close enough.  While the space seemed smaller than I had imagined, it was every bit as inspiring as I knew it would be.  Bound in its own time, of course.  Art deco mixed with classical inspiration and a narrow vision of "how shall we meet," but an inspiration nonetheless.

As I sat on the edge of the stage, my eyes prickled with tears.  I was at the heart of the Movement (metaphorically speaking, of course).  I was grateful to be able to experience this moment of connection.  I felt a sense of the past, a thread of connection to the present, with both continuity and change, but with a bedrock faith in the inherent worth of each individual person.  I'd like to return to that space--to sit and think a while on where we are today, where we need to go, but I think that would just be an indulgence at this point.  It is the people, not the places nor the things, that make us a Movement.  It is with the people--in conversation, dialogue, discussion, the search for consensus--that we will find a way through the current jumble that is facing us with our national organization.  I look forward to just such dialogue.

Thursday, September 28, 2023

Give (Local) Peace (Work) a Chance


A friend, knowing my interest in supporting a culture of peace, recently sent me this link to an article by H. Patricia Hynes about a local peace project.  Hynes talks about getting a whole community involved in positive promotion of the culture of peace, which is helpful in building a proactive, pro-peace pattern of community interaction.  Shops in Greenfield, MA, participate in the "Shops for Peace" with signs posted in their windows with peaceful messages:  "Food for All, not War."  Hynes links to research that suggests that such activities are a means of building a peace culture.  Some of the features of a peace culture referenced in that research include:  

shared identity, interconnectedness, a positive history of relationships, prosocial norms, transcendent or caring values, peace symbols, governance, and peace leaders, and additionally, peace education, peace vision, positive reciprocity, and positive goals

Reading about this project and the support in recent research, gives me a little boost for my own Peace Charm Initiative.  By the time this post is published, I will be on a plane to New York City.  I will be visiting the New York Society for Ethical Culture to talk about a couple of other projects that I am working on related to the Ethical Culture Movement, and I will be packing Peace Charms to share during meetings with my fellow Ethicals so that we all will have visible reminders of our personal roles in proactive peace building.  

While in New York, I will also be meeting with folks to talk about a project to support "caring values." I have more to learn about the project, but I already know that it will include supporting women in India (and elsewhere, I would hope) in asserting the value of the care work that women do.  This will, I expect, involve enhancing the communities' understanding that care work is important, a valuable and essential contribution to the economic and social well-being of the community, and should be granted a higher status in any accounting for value of both the caregiver and the service provided.  Since we also have this set of social problems in the US at both ends of the spectrum, I can see some potential for "local" efforts to include communities here as well.  These problems usually diminish women, who are assumed to be the caregivers, which then encourages dismissal of the importance of giving care--and providing that service with paid and qualified workers. 

It's time to stretch ourselves to make a connection between the value of care and caring values.  This is a path to peace as well as a path to equity.


Thursday, September 21, 2023

The Supremacy of Skin

The Sepia Rainbow

I've been thinking about skin.  It started when my great granddaughter discovered the skin on my arm.  It was wrinkled and loose--and made her laugh.  

Old lady skin is not really all that funny, but it is odd.  As we get older, our skin may get stretched and, eventually, lose its elasticity.  So it wrinkles.  Rapid weight loss, inactivity, deconditioning are among the factors that can contribute to the amount of wrinkles and general looseness, and I seem to have a lot of those contributions.

Another thing that happens with old skin is that it gets more spots.  Age spots.  Liver spots.  The barnacles of age (including skin tags).  A little sun can emphasize those spots, darkening them, but also highlighting the spaces where no pigment is present.  All those little scars now show up in bright contrast to any skin that begins to show its melanin levels.

Thinking about skin and all these changes, I also had to wonder why my skin--white skin--is so privileged in our American Society.  Globally, white skin is pretty uncommon.  There are only small areas of the planet where white skin naturally occurs, and, while the population that has white skin is quite numerous today, white-skinned humans are--today--still a minority of human inhabitants of Earth.  

The image I posted above should be credited to Gail McCormick, the artist who made this cut-paper illustration from a map by Nina Jablonski and George Chaplin.  The map shows the distribution of skin color that comes from the production of melanin.  Melanin is produced in response to ultraviolet rays, blocking the harmful effects of those rays.  We might think that the obvious reason for so much melanin in the tropical areas of the planet has to do with the effects of UV rays on the skin (think skin cancer).  Jablonski's research, however, shows a deeper (than skin) reason for the need for more protection from UV:  the production of folate, which is needed for human reproduction.  Too much UV, not so much folate.  A reversal of sorts occurred later, as humans migrated out of Africa and arrived in the colder, less sunny regions of the planet.  Too little UV, too little Vitamin D, lots of rickets and other bone density issues.  

Interestingly, high levels of melanin also tracks with lactose intolerance.  At the same time populations were evolving to get more benefit from UV (skin cancers tend to show up later, after the reproductive years) they also evolved the capacity to consume milk from herd animals to increase the Vitamin D in their diet.  (See Marvin Harris, Good to Eat: Riddles of Food and Culture.)

I recently had a conversation with a dear friend about skin color and colorism.  He opined that eventually there would be enough intermarriage and mingling of populations that humans would all be a nice cafe-au-lait shade of brown and we could just be done with racism.  I agreed.  Populations meet, populations mingle, reproduction occurs.  The global majority is not white, so the chances are that, over time, there could be a leveling out of this skin color issue.  After all race and racism are both human constructs that contribute to violence and war, and we need less of both.  

Still, I couldn't help but think about what is happening on the planet right now.  We are seeing significant levels of migration away from the tropics.  The effects of global warming are real and intolerable.  As climate changes, more humans will seek to move to more tolerable spaces, farther north or south toward the poles, and right into those temperate bands where too much melanin becomes a health problem.  How will humans adjust?  Will we evolve toward less melanin?  That would really be an ugly outcome--the populations that are doing the most to destroy the habitat of melanin-rich populations occupy the habitat that is most inhospitable to melanin-rich skin.  

Jablonski is working to bring more public awareness and understanding of the issues that arise from skin color.  It's just skin, after all.  The surface.  Not the heart.  Not the mind.  Not the person.  We have so many, much bigger issues to deal with than how much melanin our ancestors gave us.  My great granddaughter's interest in the changes that age has brought to my skin makes me realize that now is the time to talk to her about the colors in my skin and where they come from.  Evolution might be a tough concept for a second grader, but human worth, regardless of skin color is an age-appropriate topic for discussion any time.  The sooner the better.